We Need to Address the Racism in Muslim and Arab Spaces
By Aulla Elhassan

People of color are not a monolith, and being marginalized in one sense does not mean you can’t be bigoted or privileged in another. Individuals and communities can contribute to the same systems of oppression that harm them.
Some months ago, I had a major falling out with two of my closest Arab friends. One of them had sent me racist videos mocking Somali people and fueling misinformation about Somali Americans operating fraudulent daycare centers, which have been debunked repeatedly. When I told her that it was reprehensible to demonize an entire demographic in the way she was doing, especially for something completely unfounded, she doubled down, and our other friend reiterated the same sentiment.
“I’m not saying racism doesn’t play a part in it, but you don’t think any of them are doing it? I don’t get why you’re getting so upset about this,” she said.
That was when my illusion of solidarity between all Muslims—regardless of cultural or ethnic background— finally shattered. I remember sitting there, dumbfounded. Of course, they were describing a mindset that was detestable in any context, but it was particularly hard for me to wrap my head around the fact they were feeding into the same racist rhetoric behind this smear campaign against Somali Americans that they themselves had fallen victim to.
I wish I could say that was the only time I’d witnessed or experienced racism from Arabs at my university, but unfortunately, I have worse horror stories to tell.
The Muslims I met during my undergraduate studies were the only ones I had ever really interacted with outside of the ones I had known and grew up alongside my entire life. I’d dealt with racism many times before, but that was the first time it came from
Muslims towards other Muslims. It was like being doused with ice water. I’d never felt conscious of my Blackness in any Muslim spaces before that, never been treated by Arab Muslims who possessed a lighter complexion like I was “beneath” them until that point in time.
You expect that sort of thing from anyone else. But watching someone face prejudice and discrimination for a part of their identity—especially a part that you share with them—only for them to subject you to that same abuse? It’s a different level of betrayal.
I retreated from the Muslims on my campus— all of them, not just the ones who had personally been racist to me. I couldn’t understand why. The people I had come across very well could have just been a few bad apples, right?
I reported on a guest lecture about the ways discrimination impacts group identification for my university’s newspaper, and that allowed me to break down the psychology behind why I receded from my own community.
The lecture centered around group identification and how it relates to a person’s sense of belonging, connection, and psychological attachment to a specific social or cultural group. It greatly informs self-conceptualization. The study I examined concluded that when you face discrimination from someone you share an in-group with, it leads you to identify less with that shared in-group, and in some cases, withdraw completely—also known as rejection disidentification. Rejection disidentification was found to have disastrous effects on self-esteem and self-image.
I felt cautious when entering Arab Muslim spaces because of my previous experience with racism with other Arab Muslims who possessed a lighter complexion. I didn’t want to automatically assume there would be an inherent community to be found with them just because we share the same faith. I imagine non-Arab Muslims and Arab Muslims with a darker complexion have been conditioned into similar mindsets and also experienced rejection disidentification. But why is that the case?
The Arabization of Islam
For one, many people treat the words ‘Arab’ and ‘Muslim’ as synonymous, even though Arabs only make up about 15% to 20% of the Muslim population. Much of this can be attributed to the Arabization of Islam, which has made Arabs feel that they have a superior ‘claim’ to the religion (even though Islam reached other societies before Arabs.)
This manifests in many problematic ideologies, namely Arab ethnic supremacy– in direct contradiction of Islamic teachings.
There are dimensions to this, too. Even Black Arabs hold anti-black viewpoints. One key example is the racial hierarchy in Sudan that places Northern Sudanese people, who are Afro-Arabs, above Indigenous Black Muslims in the region. This way of thinking deposits that Northern Sudanese people are the only legitimate Muslims in the area solely because they are part Arab. Leaders used this hierarchy to justify land dispossession, resource extraction, and mass violence in Darfur, culminating in one of the worst humanitarian catastrophes of the 21st century.
Islam rejects racism and prejudice in all forms. In fact, the Quran suggests that the creation of various skin colors, languages, and nations are a sign of Allah’s greatness. It’s stated in Surah Al Rum that, “among His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth and the diversity of your languages and your colors. Verily, in that are signs for people of knowledge.” Scholars and teachings from the last prophet of Islam (PBUH) also repeatedly emphasize that piety is the sole metric of righteousness.
Black and South Asian Muslims, especially, are treated as less knowledgeable, important, and relevant. One UK study found that over 82 percent of Muslims had witnessed anti-black racism from family and friends.
But it’s not just personal or cultural attitudes, either— it’s systemic. During the Umayyad Caliphate (661-750 CE), non-Arab reverts (who were mainly Persian, Berbers, and Arameans) were forced to keep paying poll and land taxes reserved only for non-Muslim civilians— even though their conversion to Islam should have made them exempt from these taxes. Non-Arab Muslim reverts generally held a lower place in Arab society.
In the present day, we see Arab nations like Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Jordan, Bahrain, Kuwait, and more run on the subjugation of black and brown people. These countries operate variations of the Kafala system, which give employers total control over migrant workers—who are primarily from African and South Asian countries—autonomy to enter, live, work, or exit the host country. The Kafala system has been equated to modern-day slavery by major international human rights organizations and advocacy groups such as Human Rights Watch, Walk Free, and Amnesty International. The power imbalance leaves workers vulnerable to trafficking, unpaid labor, false imprisonment, abuse, and more civil and human rights abuses.
Colorism is a major issue in Arab communities as well. Colorism is a byproduct of colonialism. It was designed to divide and conquer oppressed groups, to be a means of self-colonization. Colorism gives lighter-skinned people access to better opportunities, positions them as the standard of beauty, and enforces internalized racism. It also correlates darker skin with lower class standing and feeds into anti-black racism.
Arab proximity to whiteness throughout history cannot be removed from its racist patterns today.
This is of course not to say that all Arabs are racist. It is to illustrate that Arabs have privilege over their Black and brown counterparts, and while that does not discount the oppression they face, it is a contributing factor to the marginalization of non-Arabs and Arabs with darker complexions.
So, where do we go from here?
There’s always been a unanimous effort to dismantle racism on an institutional level, but I suggest that it starts with our personal connections. It’s harder to hold our friends, family, and romantic partners accountable. But what are institutional systems built and sustained by? Individuals. When we confront racism in our day-to-day lives, we not only mitigate it for individuals, we combat the underlying culture that allows institutional racism to exist and persist in the first place.
It’s also important we hold each other accountable. The jokes we tolerate, the microaggressions we overlook, every time we ignore a clear transgression to “keep the peace"—it all feeds into white supremacy and the Arab superiority complex.
I know firsthand how hard it is to be the outlier in a space with Arabs who have a lighter complexion. You get used to being diminished. You know that the second you confront the behavior, you will be the one that is flipped as the aggressor. You’ve been told over and over that “it’s just a joke” and you’re making a big deal out of nothing.
And that’s exactly why we have to confront it. Not just for the sake of our own dignity, but because every time we stay silent, the more those attitudes become normalized.









Comments